Re: 1v1 Ladder refusing matches

2019-08-16T04:02:52+02:00

Thanks for the replies guys, glad to see I'm not losing my goddamn mind. I have 2 global matches and over 700 ladder matches so that explains it.

Statistics: Posted by Mlawrance — 16 Aug 2019, 04:02

Re: 1v1 Ladder refusing matches

2019-08-15T23:24:21+02:00

Not sure if that will solve the problem.
I've been having issues for weeks now and have more than 10 games. Tonight has been the record - over 1 hour searching and no matches when over 1000 players are online.
The "1v1 ranked Match Available " message pops up frequently, sometimes many at the same time but it never connects

Statistics: Posted by SSSX — 15 Aug 2019, 23:24

Re: 1v1 Ladder refusing matches

2019-08-15T21:52:29+02:00

Askaholic wrote:
Thanks forums for not letting me post links

xD
https://github.com/FAForever/server/issues/446

Statistics: Posted by Katharsas — 15 Aug 2019, 21:52

Re: 1v1 Ladder refusing matches

2019-08-15T19:41:08+02:00

Literally 9

playerStats.player.login=="*Mlawrance*";featuredMod.technicalName!="*ladder*"

Statistics: Posted by armacham01 — 15 Aug 2019, 19:41

Re: 1v1 Ladder refusing matches

2019-08-15T19:16:54+02:00

How many global games do you have? There is a bug which will be fixed in the next server update where the matchmaker will lower the rating it uses to match you if you have fewer than 10 global games. This is supposed to happen when you have fewer than 10 ladder games, but it was coded incorrectly.

See: github com FAForever server pull 472

Thanks forums for not letting me post links

Statistics: Posted by Askaholic — 15 Aug 2019, 19:16

1v1 Ladder refusing matches

2019-08-15T01:14:46+02:00

Hi folks.

There appears to be a problem with 1v1 ladder matching, at least in my case. My ladder ranking is ~1,100 yet I only get matched with individuals in the 500-700 range, even when other members at 1,100 are queued up. Initially I believed that perhaps no one of my rank was queuing, but it turned out that the ladder will never match me with certain players of approximately my rank no matter how long we are queued for. I would assume this is a location based problem but I frequently match with Russian, Ukranian, UK, and Polish players of 500-700 rank, but never with USA (or any other location) 1100 rankers. My current 1v1 rating is 1115 at time of writing this.

This came to a head last night when another 1100 ranker (demonstreamer666) asked for people to queue for ladder with him, and I was already queued. I confirmed with him he was queued and we both sat there for 30+ minutes without getting matched with each other or anyone else. FAF seems to prefer to give certain people no matches at all over matching them together, even if their ranks are nearly identical.

I've included the chat log from that period of time as we're discussing this issue below:

[SCR] demonstreamer666
!to ladder
9:29 PM
TheSetoner
believes demonstreamer666 needs to climb the ladder of enlightenment to use this command...
9:29 PM
[SCR] demonstreamer666
GO LADDER PUSSIES
9:36 PM
Mlawrance
I'm queued for ladder but I won't match you.
9:38 PM
QAI
Please remain in your ladder search for at least 3 minutes. There is a new queue system in place that starts matches on a fixed interval.
9:38 PM
[SCR] demonstreamer666
why?
u scared of micro of the Master?
9:44 PM
Mlawrance
No. I mean it physically won't match us because the ladder is broken.
It won't match me with you even though our ranks are almost the same.
9:47 PM
[ONI] SCP-096
wait 3 min
9:47 PM
Mlawrance
I will wait 30 minutes and match the same rank 200 as always
9:47 PM
bonestardoa
geography based?
9:48 PM
Mlawrance
The ladder is not working properly. I can watch demonstreamer and other people of my similar rank in the vault queuing at the same time as me and they will never match me.
IDK, I match Ukranian 300 ranks all the time.
9:48 PM
_Discord
FtXCommando: literally nothing has changed in the matching process aside from the interval introduction
9:48 PM
Mlawrance
Regardless of what you think is going on, empirically I can confirm there are several players of my rank that I will never get matched with no matter how long we queue up together.
Demonstreamer is one of them.
BRS_Destructor also.
9:49 PM
_Discord
FtXCommando: either 1) these players ur rating are matching with others to create more optimal games 2) they arent searching the proper time needed 3) connection issues
FtXCommando: if not these, the problem would have existed in the old system
FtXCommando: because none of that code was touched in any way
9:49 PM
Mlawrance
It's possible they predate the interval implementation.
9:50 PM
Mlawrance
If you're aware of how the ladder matching works, FTX.
Is it possible that it is also using global rating?
I don't play anything but ladder so I have no global rating.
9:52 PM
_Discord
FtXCommando: global has never been used in ladder
9:55 PM
Mlawrance
Then I honestly have no explanation whatsoever.
9:55 PM
_Discord
FtXCommando: ladder USED to influence global rating in 2013-2014 but that’s the extent of their relation
9:55 PM
Mlawrance
Demonstreamer is queued right now. Both of us have been queued for a long time now, Way more than the interval. Our ranks are 1100 both.
But it'd rather give us no match whatsoever than put us together.
9:56 PM
_Discord
FtXCommando: has he ever gotten a game?
biass: Not being able to farm destructor
biass: Why live?
9:56 PM
Mlawrance
Yeah, he plays with other people than I do.
9:56 PM
[SCR] demonstreamer666
im in search
9:57 PM
Mlawrance
It's like we're playing with totally different pools of people.
9:57 PM
[SCR] demonstreamer666
20 mins
so
9:57 PM
Mlawrance
I've never seen him or anyone he's played against in any of my matches.
9:57 PM
_Discord
FtXCommando: it isnt really possible for me to explain anything properly without knowing both your trueskill ratings
9:57 PM
Mlawrance
Is there a way for me to recover that information?
9:57 PM
_Discord
FtXCommando: but java client has decided that isnt info worth giving players for some reason
9:57 PM
[SCR] demonstreamer666
1100 ladder 1200 global
9:57 PM
_Discord
FtXCommando: shown rating != trueskill rating
FtXCommando: your shown rating is 3*sigma less than your trueskill value
9:58 PM
Mlawrance
I am aware. I am asking if there is a way to see that.
9:58 PM
[SCR] demonstreamer666
!= trueskill rating
shown rating != trueskill rating
9:58 PM
_Discord
FtXCommando: python client shows trueskill next to your shown rating
FtXCommando: idk if java has a way to see it, dont think it does
9:59 PM
Mlawrance
Java doesn't seem to.
Well, all I know is that there's a bunch of dudes I'd really like to match with and instead it makes me slap people half my rank around all day.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
9:59 PM
_Discord
FtXCommando: i mean it’s technically possible that everyone kept getting games aside from you
FtXCommando: and the system ultimately relegates you to face people far lower
10:00 PM
Mlawrance
Well, I think the real knock to that is that demonstreamer and I are both not getting games right now.
It could match us together but it won't.
10:01 PM
_Discord
FtXCommando: sure and if that is really happening id like to know shown rating and trueskill rating so devs can test it on a test server
10:01 PM
TheSetoner
starts a balance riot!
10:01 PM
TheSetoner
"Absolutely nothing is OP about aeon in my opinion."
10:01 PM
_Discord
FtXCommando: to see if it’s an issue with matchmaking or what
10:01 PM
Mlawrance
I'll send this chat as a log and explain it in a ticket then.

As you can see, a more experienced player suggested someone might be able to verify that this is working correctly? I suspect it isn't.

Statistics: Posted by Mlawrance — 15 Aug 2019, 01:14

Forged Alliance Forever

Re: 1v1 Ladder refusing matches

Re: 1v1 Ladder refusing matches

Re: 1v1 Ladder refusing matches

Re: 1v1 Ladder refusing matches

Re: 1v1 Ladder refusing matches

1v1 Ladder refusing matches